
Eat & drink
Hidden gems in Staten Island, 2026
27 independent Staten Island places rated 4.6★ or higher on Google that still have fewer than 300 reviews.
Updated October 2026 · 27 independent places in Staten Island
Where they are in Staten Island
Map of 27 places loads as you scroll.
How this list is made
A place is listed when its Google rating is 4.6 or higher from 20 to 300 reviews: rated highly by the people who have been, but not yet one of Staten Island’s most-reviewed spots. Places are ranked by rating × log10(review count).
Only independent local businesses in this guide’s Staten Island directory are included: no chains and no places outside Staten Island. Listings that are held or unpublished are left out.
Hours are each business’s posted weekly schedule as saved in this guide. They can change and do not cover holidays, so confirm before you go.
Google ratings are snapshots checked September 2026; places with fewer than 10 reviews show no rating.
Updated October 2026.
Hidden gems in Staten Island: answers
What are the hidden gem restaurants in Staten Island?
The top-ranked are La Vera Pizzeria (4.9★, 274 reviews), Tabla on the Island (4.9★, 259 reviews) and Problem Baker (4.9★, 230 reviews).
How are hidden gems chosen?
A place is listed when its Google rating is 4.6 or higher from 20 to 300 reviews: rated highly by the people who have been, but not yet one of Staten Island’s most-reviewed spots. Places are ranked by rating × log10(review count).
Why aren’t the most popular Staten Island restaurants on this list?
Places with more than 300 Google reviews are already well known, so they are left out on purpose; you will find them on the main eat and drink page.
What kinds of food are among Staten Island’s hidden gems?
Mexican restaurant (10), Pizza restaurant (2), Cafe (2), Bakery (2) and Coffee shop (2).
Are these hidden gems independent businesses?
Yes. Every place is an independent local business in this guide’s Staten Island directory; chains are not listed.
